Why are fake reviews a legal risk?
Because they mislead buyers, and Indian law protects buyers from being misled. A seller who buys fifty five-star reviews for a new pressure cooker is telling buyers something untrue. That can be seen as an unfair trade practice. It can also hurt you on marketplaces and in search. The good news is that the rules are simple. Collect real reviews from real buyers, and publish them honestly.
What do the E-Commerce Rules say?
The Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules, 2020 speak to this directly. A seller who owns the stock it sells online must not pose as a buyer and post reviews. It also must not lie about the quality or features of what it sells. So writing reviews of your own products under made-up names is ruled out. The same rules ask every e-commerce entity to have a grievance officer for complaints.
What does the BIS review standard cover?
The Bureau of Indian Standards issued IS 19000:2022 on online consumer reviews. It covers how reviews are gathered, checked and shown. BIS’s scheme for the standard lists the problems it targets. They include fake positive reviews written by sellers and false negative reviews written by competitors. They also include sellers who remove negative reviews, and sellers who stop buyers from writing negative ones. Sellers who want certification apply to BIS under that scheme, so read it before you claim to follow the standard.
Which practices should you avoid?
| Practice | Why it is a problem |
|---|---|
| Writing positive reviews of your own products | Misleads buyers about quality |
| Posting negative reviews of a competitor | Named in the BIS scheme as a problem |
| Hiding or deleting honest negative reviews | Shows a false picture |
| Paying or rewarding only five-star reviews | Biases what buyers read |
| Penalising buyers who leave bad reviews | Named in the BIS scheme as a problem |
A review policy you can adopt
- Accept reviews only from buyers who bought the product, where you can.
- Publish every review that follows your rules, positive or negative.
- Remove only reviews with abuse, personal details or spam, and say so in your policy.
- If you offer any thank-you, offer it for any honest review, not only good ones.
- Label any review from staff or partners clearly.
- Reply to complaints in public, politely, and fix the cause.
Where should the policy live?
Put a short review policy on your website, near your other policy pages, and link it from your product pages. Two or three paragraphs are enough. Say who can review, how reviews are checked and what you remove. Buyers rarely read it, but its presence shows you take reviews seriously. If a complaint ever comes, it shows you had a fair process. Review the policy once a year, and update it when the rules or your own process change.
Moderation on The Storemate
On The Storemate, the Require purchase setting is on by default, so only customers who bought a product can review it. You also choose whether new reviews wait for your approval. Each review can be approved, rejected or replied to from Catalog, then Reviews.