Why is loyalty ROI easy to get wrong?
Because your best buyers would have bought anyway. If you compare members’ spending with non-members’, members always look great. That is because loyal people join loyalty programs. The real question is how much extra buying the program caused. A program that gives ₹50,000 of rewards a month to buyers who would have ordered regardless is a cost, not an investment.
What is the formula?
ROI is extra profit minus program cost, divided by program cost. Extra profit is the margin on orders members placed because of the program. Program cost includes rewards redeemed, free shipping given, any app fees and your time. Use margin, not revenue. For example, if the program brought ₹2 lakh of extra sales at 40% margin, that is ₹80,000 of extra profit. If it cost ₹30,000, ROI is about 1.7 times.
Which metrics matter?
| Metric | What it tells you | Healthy sign |
|---|---|---|
| Repeat purchase rate | How many members buy again | Rises after joining |
| Redemption rate | Points spent out of points issued | Steady, not near zero |
| Order value | Basket size of members | Holds or grows |
| Reward cost | Rewards and free shipping given | Below the extra margin |
| Points owed | Unspent points as a rupee amount | Grows slower than sales |
How do you measure the extra?
Compare members with themselves. Take buyers who joined three months ago and compare their orders in the three months before and after joining. Or compare members who joined with similar buyers who did not, matched by past spending. Neither is perfect, but both beat a raw member versus non-member comparison. Keep it simple. A rough honest number is more useful than a precise flattering one.
What costs do people forget?
Free shipping and free products are the usual ones. A free shipping reward costs you the courier charge on that order. A free product costs its price, and under CBIC’s Circular 92/11/2019-GST input tax credit is not available on goods given away free. Unspent points are another hidden cost. They are rewards you still owe, so keep an eye on the total and on expiry.
A monthly loyalty ROI check
- Note rewards redeemed, free shipping given and any app fees this month.
- Compare repeat orders of recent joiners before and after joining.
- Multiply the extra orders by your margin, not your revenue.
- Divide the extra profit minus costs by the costs.
- Check redemption rate and points owed for warning signs.
What should you change if ROI is low?
Look at the rewards first. If redemption is low, rewards may be too far away or unappealing. If redemption is high but repeat orders flat, rewards may be going to buyers who would have bought anyway. Try making the first reward come on the second order, which is often the hardest one to win. Then measure again after another cycle.
Loyalty numbers on The Storemate
On The Storemate, the Loyalty app’s Analytics tab shows points issued, redeemed, expired and reversed, the redemption rate, active members, members against non-members and what you owe in unspent points, with a comparison to the previous period and a CSV export.