Why do online royalties cause disputes?
Because online sales have more moving parts than counter sales. A cash sale at the till is done. An online order can be discounted, paid by COD, returned, refunded in part or never delivered. If the agreement says only “6% royalty on sales”, the brand and franchisee will count those cases differently. One month of arguing over a ₹4,000 difference can sour the relationship. Clear definitions prevent it.
What should royalty be charged on?
| Question | Common choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Before or after GST? | Before tax | Tax is not the franchisee’s income |
| Before or after discount? | After discount | Royalty follows what the buyer paid |
| Brand products only, or all sales? | Depends on the agreement | Own products may be excluded |
| Shipping charges? | Usually excluded | Delivery is a cost, not a sale |
When does an online sale count?
When the money is real. Many agreements count a prepaid order when its payment lands, and a cash on delivery order when it is delivered. An order that comes back to the sender never counts. Writing this down stops arguments over orders placed on the last day of a month but delivered on the first day of the next. Pick the rule and apply it the same way every period.
How should refunds be handled?
Deduct them in the period they happen, at the original rate. If a ₹3,000 order paid in September is refunded in October, October’s statement shows a deduction. September’s statement stays as it was. This keeps every statement final. If refunds in a quiet month are larger than sales, carry the shortfall into the next statement rather than sending a negative bill.
What should a statement show?
- The period it covers, with start and end dates.
- Each sale counted, with its base value before tax and after discount.
- Each refund deducted, at the original line’s rate.
- The royalty rate and the total royalty due.
- Any amount carried from or to another statement.
Who is the seller, and why does it matter?
The franchisee, if their name and GSTIN are on the invoice. That matters for royalty because the sale is theirs, and royalty is a separate charge from the brand to them. India’s Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules, 2020 ask an e-commerce entity to show its legal name, address and grievance officer details. So the franchisee’s site shows the franchisee, and the brand bills royalty to that business. GST applies to royalty as a service, so agree the treatment with your accountants.
How often should statements run?
Match the period to the size of the franchise. Weekly statements suit busy stores that want quick settlement. Monthly is the most common. Quarterly suits small franchisees with modest online sales. Whatever you pick, issue each statement at the same time after the period ends, and do not change it afterwards. A statement that changes later is a statement nobody trusts.
Royalty statements on The Storemate
On The Storemate, franchise statements follow the terms you set. A line’s base is its value before tax, after its discount, and a prepaid order counts when paid while a COD order counts when delivered. Refunds are deducted in the period they are made, and a statement never changes once issued. The franchisee pays the brand directly.